Review: No Castles Here
September 7, 2011
Bauer, A.C.E. (2007). No castles here. New York, NY: Random House Books for Young Readers. 288 p. 978-037593921. $15.99. Gr. 4-8.
Augie Boretski leads a hard life. His father left. He lives in a neighborhood overrun by drug dealers. He’s constantly bullied. And, worst of all, his mom is making him join the Big Brothers program. When he finds a beat-up book of fairy tales, Augie begins to believe in magic and in himself. Bauer mixes gritty realism with a dark fairy tale world in an uneven, but enjoyable, coming of age story. The characters are strong and likable, especially Augie, who seems ripped from the pages of Norman Juster or Daniel Pinkwater. The problem lies with Bauer trying to do too much. Augie is bullied. Then he finds out his Big Brother is gay, which he doesn’t handle well. His school’s choir is in constant threat of being ended. Then his school gets closed down. Bauer just keeps piling it on, before rushing to tie up the loose ends.
Uggh. Terrible cover and uneven book.
Similar Titles (From Books and Authors): Adam Canfield of the Slash – Michael Winerip, The Black Book of Secrets – F.E. Higgins, The Dancing Pancake – Eileen Spinelli; Joanne Lew-Vriethoff, I Am Not Joey Pigza – Jack Gantos, The Invention of Hugo Cabret: A Novel in Words and Pictures – Brian Selznick, The Last Newspaper Boy in America – Sue Corbett, The Mysterious Benedict Society – Trenton Lee Stewart, Seven-Day Magic – Edward Eager; N.M. Bodecker, What Happened on Fox Street – Tricia Springstubb